A tension sometimes
arises between Buddhist teachings and Western attitudes towards anger.
When I give a talk on anger, describing how to work with it, how to
not be controlled by it, and how to let go of it, inevitably someone
will say, “I don’t think that anger is bad or that we need
to get rid of it; it can play an important role in our lives.”
One of the issues between Buddhist and western cultural understandings
of anger is the assumption that the English use of the word “anger”
is the same as the Buddhist use. Often, they are referring to somewhat
different experiences.
The Buddhist word dosa is usually translated as anger. But
it would probably be more accurate to translate it as “hostility,”
provided that we recognize that hostility can be present in emotions
ranging from minor annoyance to full-blown rage. While the English word
anger can include hostility, it doesn’t have to. The West has
a long tradition of accepting certain forms of anger as appropriate
responses, for example, a forceful protest against injustice.
Dosa burns the one who is angry. Classic Buddhist teachings
liken being angry to holding a red-hot piece of coal. For Buddhists,
acting on dosa is never justified; dosa is a form
of suffering that Buddhist practice is designed to alleviate.
One ancient Buddhist text likens dosa to “urine mixed
with poison.” In ancient India, urine was considered to have medicinal
properties; it was unpleasant but beneficial. However, when urine is
mixed with poison, the unpleasant medicine becomes harmful. At times
a forceful “No!” is required of us even though it may be
unpleasant. But an energized “no” mixed with hostility is
like mixing urine with poison.
Dosa holds people out of our hearts, away from our kindness
and care. We don’t necessarily need to avoid anger, but we do
need to guard ourselves from locking others out of our hearts.
How can we work with this difficult emotion?
Meditation can be very helpful. In it we can experience our anger without
inhibitions, judgments, or interpretations. It can be a relief to discover
a capacity for witnessing anger without either pushing it away or engaging
with it. In fact, meditation may well be the safest place to be angry,
to learn to let it flow through us freely, without either condemnation
or approval.
With non-reactive mindfulness as the foundation, we can investigate
anger deeply through the body, emotions and thoughts. Anger can open
us to a world of self-discovery.
Anger tends to be directed outward towards an object, towards other
people, events, or even parts of ourselves. In mindfulness meditation,
we turn the mind away from the object
of anger to study the source of the anger and the subjective experience
of being angry.
We can investigate anger through the sensations of the body. The direct
experience of anger may result in sensations of heat, tightness, pulsation
or contraction. The breathing may become heavy or rapid, and the heart
may beat strongly. Since these sensations are direct and immediate,
bringing attention to them helps lessen the preoccupation with the object
of the anger and with the story of why we are angry. This in turn, helps
us to be more fully present for the anger in and of itself.
Turning our attention away from the object of our anger is important
because, while the conditions giving rise to anger may be varied, the
direct causes of hostile anger are found within the person who is angry.
The causes include aversion, grasping, resentment, fear, defensiveness
and other reactions that may be unnecessary and are often the source
of the greatest pain in a difficult situation. A traditional folk saying
states, “An enemy can hurt you physically; but if the enemy wants
to hurt your heart, you have to help by getting angry.”
Hostile anger seems to have its roots in recoiling from our own pain.
We may react to our own sadness, loneliness, fear, disappointment or
hurt by directing anger outwards rather than experiencing these feelings.
Learning to honestly and non-reactively explore our pain through the
mind and bodily sensations is an important step to freedom.
In my own life, I’ve learned that my anger tends to have two primary
causes: fear and hurt. When I get angry, if it seems appropriate, I
remove myself from the situation and try to be mindful of what is going
on inside. If I can find the fear or the hurt underlying the anger,
then (if possible) I’ll go back into the situation and speak from
the perspective of being hurt or afraid. Conversations tend to be more
helpful when I do this, partly because I am not assigning blame. This
often lessens the other person’s defensiveness or reactivity;
they may even be more inclined to see their own responsibility.
Anger is always a signal. Mindfulness helps reveal what it signals.
Sometimes it is a signal that something in the external world needs
to be addressed. Sometimes it is a signal that something is off internally.
If nothing else, anger is a signal that someone is suffering. Probably
it is you. Sit still in the midst of your anger and find your freedom.